Fantastic Read...
I read this book in one afternoon, I can't remember the last time I did
that. I really could not put it down. The stories were great, I loved the
insights into the relationship between Holmes and Watson and as I have
read Doyle in the past I can honestly say the writer was very authentic in
capturing the dynamic between the two beautifully. I really recommend this
book, wonderfully told stories where mystery abounds. Five Stars. I will
be keeping an eye out for any further publications from this author.
© Christina George, 2014
Reproduced by kind permission
Christina is the author of
The Rise of the
Sidhe
Requiem For Sherlock Holmes...
.....is a recent Holmes collection written by Paul Stuart Hayes and
published by Hidden Tiger. This is the author's first Sherlock Holmes book
but you would not guess that from the quality of the stories. They are
uniformly excellent, detailed, well-plotted and with a Watsonian voice
straight from the canon.
The centre-piece is the novella which kickstarts the collection, The
Ancestral Horror. We meet Holmes' father who is languishing in jail
accused of murder. We get Holmes' customary brilliance in solving the
crime, but we also get a fascinating insight into the relationship between
father and son. Now, the relationship is strained to the point of
non-existence and the reasons lie deep in the past. Holmes is not
portrayed as a saint and even Watson has to question whether he really
knows Holmes. The author plays fair all along and we along with Watson
have to determine for ourselves where to apportion blame. It is a
wonderful bonus to go hand in hand with Holmesian writing of the highest
order. The dialogue throughout is exemplary, the experience authentic.
This is one of those collections which requires further reading to capture
all the nuances in its pages.
Now, as you may have surmised the novella is a towering achievement, but
don't think for a moment that the other stories are mere filler. They are
not. They are every bit as good. Here is an author who loves his
characters, loves putting words in their mouths and we the readers are the
ones who benefit. If you enjoy Sherlock Holmes collections you will be
hard pushed to find a better one around at the moment. If I had written it
I would be glowing with pride. Well done, Paul.
© David Ruffle, 2013
Reproduced by kind permission
David is the author of the acclaimed Sherlock Holmes
Lyme Regis trilogy comprising
Sherlock Holmes and the Lyme Regis Horror
Sherlock Holmes and the Lyme Regis Legacy
Sherlock Holmes and the Lyme Regis Trials
Sir
Arthur Conan Doyle's legendary creation Sherlock Holmes has recently
undergone a modern reinvention through BBC Television's Sherlock,
but in Paul Stuart Hayes' Requiem for Sherlock Holmes, we find
Holmes and Watson back in the period which we as fans are most familiar
with; hansom cabs and telegrams are the height of technology and there's
not an iPhone or skyscraper in sight!
Through most of the book I was reminded of the actor Jeremy
Brett, the greatest Holmes of all to my mind. This feeling is heightened
as The Ancestral Horror kicks into gear, depicting Holmes at his
most enigmatic and brilliant. At the story's heart is the catalyst of a
dark, suppressed family secret, and as the plot twists and turns, it
brings even the ever-dependable Watson to question whether his friend is
being wholly honest with him. The story is a well paced and clever
pastiche which harks back to Conan Doyle's style and evokes the period
vividly.
The author clearly has a deep love and understanding of
Doyle's creation and his portrayal of the characters of Holmes and Watson
is pitch perfect. The other stories in Requiem for Sherlock Holmes
are equally as engaging and varied, with nods and rewards along the way
for Holmes afficionados and more casual readers alike. I particularly
enjoyed The Penitent Man with its supernatural undertones and the
gruesome subplot, which I will leave to the reader to discover for
themselves.
All in all, a great effort which the both author and his
publisher, Hidden Tiger, can be proud of. I look forward to reading more
from this writer and maybe his further tales of the world's greatest
detective.